The ubiquitous image of Mary, Joseph, and baby Jesus squeezed into a Bethlehem stable has a timeless appeal in artwork, crèches, and seasonal plays everywhere, but historians question many elements of its historicity. "If you ask me, Jesus was born in Nazareth," said archaeologist Dr Uzi Dahari. It was a staple in the ancient diet and provided not only comfort but nourishment necessary for survival. THE CONVERSATION via AP — Every Christmas, a relatively small town in the West Bank comes center stage: Bethlehem. Both Matthew 2 and Luke 2 state that Jesus was born in Bethlehem in Judea. “And Joseph also went up from Galilee, from the town of Nazareth, to Judea, to the city of David, which is called Bethlehem, because he was of the house and lineage of David, to be registered with Mary, his betrothed, who was with child. Moreover, the Greek word translated as “inn” (kataluma) doesn’t mean hotel in any kind of modern service industry kind of way. Though both Matthew and Luke agree that Jesus was born in Bethlehem, a number of historians argue that Jesus was actually born in Nazareth. Every Christmas, a relatively small town in the Palestinian West Bank comes center stage: Bethlehem. And after the birth of Jesus … Both evangelists go to great lengths to establish Jesus Christ as a historical person, carefully placing him in a specific historical period by referencing leaders and events at the time he was born. Pilgrims visiting Bethlehem within about 100 years of Christ’s birth already believed Christ was born there. When the wise men went to Herod with the news that a child had been born to be the king of the Jews, he made a plan to kill all young children to remove the threat to his throne. There is no guiding star in Luke’s story, nor do the shepherds bring gifts to baby Jesus. In the same way, the star of Bethlehem was also intended to present Jesus as a person of global importance. In the New Testament, the Gospel of Luke says that Jesus' parents traveled from Nazareth to Bethlehem, where Jesus was born. Did the Nativity really happen during winter in Bethlehem 2,020 years ago? More specifically, Christ was born in a stable, possibly a stable inside a cave. The story begins with wise men who come to the city of Jerusalem after seeing a star that they interpreted as signaling the birth of a new king. Early Christian traditions describe Jesus as being born in Bethlehem: in one account, a verse in the Book of Micah is interpreted as a prophecy that the Messiah would be born there. According to Matthew’s infancy narrative, Jesus was born in Bethlehem, not because of a census (which is Luke) but because Mary and Joseph lived there. You ask, "Why Was Jesus Born in Bethlehem?" Just like the comet that celebrated Caesar or the eclipse that accompanied the death of Jesus, the star of Bethlehem was supposed to herald an event of cosmic proportions. But King David was not born in Nazareth, nor associated with that city. (Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem) The claim is made by some scholars that Jesus was not born in Bethlehem. Luke mentions that Jesus is not only genealogically connected to King David, but also born in Bethlehem, “the city of David.” [Deep knowledge, daily. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter.] There’s even a scene in Franco Zeffirelli’s Jesus of Nazareth in which a woman gives the holy family directions to a cave-like dwelling. These are the only references in the New Testament to Bethlehem as Jesus’ place of birth. They journey to Bethlehem in response to a census that the Roman emperor Caesar Augustus required for all the Jewish people. Answer: It is a common saying at Christmastime that Jesus Christ was “born in a manger.” Of course, it wasn’t possible for Him to actually be born in the manger, but that’s where Mary laid Him after His birth (Luke 2:7). John Meier, a scholar on the historical Jesus, explains that Jesus’ “birth at Bethlehem is to be taken not as a historical fact” but as a “theological affirmation put into the form of an apparently historical narrative.” In other words, the belief that Jesus was a descendant of King David led to the development of a story about Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. Luke and Matthew both place Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. "Zero. It took 1,000 years for one prophecy and 700 years for the other, but God always keeps his promises. Some archaeologists believe Jesus was born in the small village of Bethlehem in the Galilee, located in northern Israel, which later became known for its Nazi-sympathiser German Templer community The New Testament Gospels do not agree about the details of Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. Tragically, she died in childbirth as Joseph’s beloved brother, Benjamin, came into the world. Even so, this doesn’t make the Jupiter-Saturn event the biblical star, nor does it mean that Jesus was necessarily born in a stable, or even in Bethlehem. : Christian tradition states that Jesus was born in Bethlehem, in Judea (now Palestine). Every Christmas, a relatively small town in the Palestinian West Bank comes center stage: Bethlehem. David Silverman/Getty Images. During the period of Jesus’ life, there were multiple perspectives on the Messiah. The Gospel of Luke includes no flight to Egypt, no paranoid King Herod, no murder of children and no wise men visiting baby Jesus. The two accounts agree that Jesus was born in Bethlehem in Judea, his mother Mary was betrothed to a man named Joseph, who was descended from King David and was not his biological father, and that his birth was caused by divine intervention. "At that time in … As most first century Jews believed that the promised messiah would be a military leader, the connection to David helped bolster Jesus’ messianic credentials. Jesus was the “new David” the “great ruler” that would come from Bethlehem and bring peace and security to all the nations (2007, p. 416). Was Jesus Really Born in Bethlehem? The question is: what is a kataluma? After Jesus was born, Joseph took his family from Bethlehem to Jerusalem for up to 40 days (Luke 2:22), and from there straight back to Nazareth (Luke 2:39). Some modern New Testament scholars believe parts of the Gospel accounts to be later accretions and hold that Jesus was born in Nazareth, his childhood home, but normative Christian belief has sanctified Bethlehem as Jesus’ birthplace for almost two millennia. In fact, this was a fulfillment of prophecy, as Matthew records: Now after Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea in the days of Herod the king, behold, wise men from the east came to Jerusalem, 2 saying, “Where is he who has been born king of the Jews? The Gospel of Luke, an account of Jesus’ life which was written during the same period as the Gospel of Matthew, has a different version of Jesus’ birth. Where was Jesus Born? Around another bend of history’s trail lies Ruth, whose story is short but moving. In challenging traditional depictions of the birth of Jesus some scholars go a lot further than just reconfiguring the sleeping plans. According to the New Testament, Joseph and Mary were living in Bethlehem of Judea at the time of Jesus' birth and later moved to Nazareth up north. Jesus, according to some Christian biblical sources, was born … The reason that we might think of this main room as a stable is that there was a manger or animal trough there. The Bible tells us that Jesus was born in the city of Bethlehem, which is just south of Jerusalem. Alexander the Great, whose empire reached from Macedonia to India, was claimed to be a son of Hercules. In a year in which good tidings of great joy were conspicuously absent, the astral event is making news. Typically, Joseph’s family would have put them up in the guest quarters that formed part of the upper rooms of the house. It may well be that Matthew has placed Jesus’ birth there to fulfill Micah’s prophecy (5:2) that a great ruler (the supposed messiah) would come from Bethlehem.. Matthew explains it all by indicating that Joseph and Mary were originally from Bethlehem. Jesus was probably born in Nazareth. Matthew also says that after Herod dies from an illness, Joseph, Mary and Jesus do not return to Bethlehem. "(Micah 5:2, HBFV throughout). But as a scholar of the New Testament, what I argue is that the Gospels offer an important insight into the Greco-Roman views of ethnic identity, including genealogies. Bethlehem was in Judea which was a Roman province. Jesus was born in a stable, not because all the hotels were full but because the guest room of the relatives with whom Joseph and Mary were staying was already overcrowded with guests. (The visit of the Magi could be claimed to fulfill Isaiah 60:3-6.) But within the Hebrew Bible, a prophetic book called Micah, thought to be written around B.C. It’s because of the lack of space, tradition tells us, that they end up in a stable and Jesus is placed in a manger. Galilee is Jesus’ hometown. Yet the New Testament Gospels do not agree about the details of Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. There they prosp… We also have these very specific descriptions of what the town was like at the time. This text is repeated in Matthew’s version. By Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Adjunct Assistant Professor of the New Testament, Fuller Theological Seminary. The Gospels’ different views might be hard to reconcile. The God of creation was born in a back-woods town and in the overflow section. Luke says these shepherds were notified about Jesus’ location in Bethlehem by angels. Tomorrow night, Jupiter and Saturn will briefly cross paths in the sky and appear to form a single body. Jesus, according to some biblical sources, was born in this town some two millennia ago. Every Christmas, a relatively small town in the Palestinian West Bank comes center stage: Bethlehem. Luke also mentions that Joseph, Mary and Jesus leave Bethlehem eight days after his birth and travel to Jerusalem and then to Nazareth. The Gospels of Mark and John reveal that they either had trouble linking Bethlehem with Jesus, did not know his birthplace, or were not concerned with this city. The ancients didn't ask how; they asked why: Jesus's name tells us: 'God with us' (Emmanuel), 'save his people from their sins.' We know that Jesus was born in Bethlehem, there was no room “in the inn,” and that he was wrapped in swaddling cloths and laid in a manger. Jesus, according to some biblical sources, was born in … Tradition places Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem, a small town a few miles south of Jerusalem. The town of Bethlehem of Judea, about six miles south of Jerusalem, has always been considered the birthplace of Jesus. Apostle Paul, who wrote the earliest documents of the New Testament, considered Jesus a descendant of David but does not associate him with Bethlehem. Jesus was born in Bethlehem in a humble and lowly state. The gospel tells us that a bright star appeared in the eastern sky when Jesus was born… After the birth, Joseph and Mary are visited not by wise men but shepherds, who were also overjoyed at Jesus’ birth. This is what he had to say about the coming Messiah: Micah 5:2 "But as for you, Bethlehem Ephrathah, Too little to be among the clans of Judah, From you One will go forth for Me to Since Joseph was a descendant of King David, Bethlehem was the hometown where he was required to register. Yesterday I discussed Matthew’s account of how it is that Jesus came to be born in Bethlehem, if in fact he “came” from Nazareth. The problem is that there’s no record of a census taking place during the reign of Augustus and even if there had been one it’s highly unlikely that people would have had to have returned to their ancestral home. For example, Ion, the founder of the Greek colonies in Asia, was considered to be a descendant of Apollo. The meaning, he writes, is that the place that he was staying did not have enough space to accommodate the soon-to-be small family. Aviram Oshri is right that, in Luke’s Gospel, it made no sense for Joseph to take the heavily pregnant Mary all the way from Nazareth in Galilee to Bethlehem in Judea, especially as the Romans would never have counted a woman. . John mentions a debate where some Jewish people referred to the prophecy which claimed that the messiah would be a descendant of David and come from Bethlehem. The story of the Star of Bethlehem appears only in the Book of Matthew. The Gospels of Matthew and Luke begin with narratives about the birth and infancy of Jesus. David Silverman/Getty Images. The problem isn’t one of vocabulary. This isn’t quite what the Bible says, however. Instead, they travel north to Nazareth in Galilee, which is modern-day Nazareth in Israel. > Was Jesus born in Bethlehem or Nazareth? Perhaps assertions that Jesus was born in Bethlehem were generally accepted, given understanding that he was David’s descendent. Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Fuller Theological Seminary. This does not mean, however, that Mary and Joseph relocated to a stable. Two widows—Ruth and Naomi, her mother-in-law—left foreign Moabfor the small town where Naomi and her husband had lived, the town of Bethlehem. According to the Gospel of Matthew, the first Gospel in the canon of the New Testament, Joseph and Mary were in Bethlehem when Jesus was born. Raymond Brown, another scholar on the Gospels, also states that “the two narratives are not only different—they are contrary to each other in a number of details.”. Star of Bethlehem as Comet . Matthew and Luke’s inclusion of the city of Bethlehem contributed to the claim that Jesus was the Messiah from a Davidic lineage. And after the angel informed him of Herod’s death, Joseph settled in Galilee rather than returning to his home in Bethlehem in Judea. The Good Shepherd — Anonymous. 1,000 years after David died, the town of Bethlehem was still known as the “town of David” (Luke 2:11). Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Fuller Theological Seminary. Jesus, according to some biblical sources, was born in this town some two millennia ago. They find the two birth stories unconvincing, and suggest that both were crafted to explain how Jesus of Nazareth somehow fulfilled the prophetic expectation of birth in David’s city of Bethlehem. Was he born in Bethlehem in Judea, or in Nazareth, or in another Bethlehem? said Dr. Oshri. The Star of Bethlehem. There are problems with those claims and I’ll come back to them in a moment. The gospel of the evangelist Matthew tells us that "Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea (now Palestine). In one stream of Jewish thought, the Messiah was expected to be an everlasting ruler from the lineage of David. In Mark and John, he’s just Jesus of Nazareth. One day God sent the angel Gabriel to Mary with a message. Overjoyed, they worship Jesus and present gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh. Luke mentions that Jesus is not only genealogically connected to King David, but also born in Bethlehem, “the city of David.”. As Bart Ehrman puts it in his New Testament Introduction, a situation like this would have been a “bureaucratic nightmare” that would have involved “massive migration.” It is unbelievable, he argues, that millions of people were uprooted for this one event, and that no other ancient sources thought to mention it. Jesus, according to some biblical sources, was born … Second, in Luke, the event that necessitates Mary and Joseph’s journey to Bethlehem is a census. The opening chapter of Mark says that Jesus is from “Nazareth of Galilee.” This is repeated throughout the Gospel on several occasions, and Bethlehem is never mentioned. The story about the journey to Bethlehem was a later invention that connected Jesus to King David. What makes it more difficult is that neither the other Gospels, that of Mark and John, mentions Jesus’ birth or his connection to Bethlehem. As the Greek historian Polybius explains, the renowned deeds of ancestors are “part of the heritage of posterity.”. Jesus, according to some biblical sources, was born in this town some two millennia ago.Yet the New Testament Gospels do not agree about the details of Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. In this story of the destitute widow and the Bethlehem man who later married, protected, and provided for her, we see a picture of Jesus, our kinsman redeemer. Jesus is Born in Bethlehem. We know this from Biblical prophesies and narrative accounts like in Luke 2:4 and Matthew 2:1. Yet the New Testament Gospels do not agree about the details of Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. Event that guided the wise men to Mary, Joseph and a pregnant Mary in,! The prophet Samuel anointed him to be a descendant of King David in.. And bread held great importance in Bible times leave Bethlehem eight days after birth. That `` Jesus was born in Nazareth seem more likely born in Bethlehem Bethlehem was Messiah! Founders and political leaders Matthew also says that after Herod dies from an illness Joseph! Born and grew up in Nazareth, among the hills of Galilee Samuel anointed him to written... King David Jesus Christ does several miracles and has brothers in Galilee,. After his birth Augustus required for all the travelers overcrowded the guest.! Via AP — every Christmas, a relatively small town a few miles south Jerusalem! Not by wise men but shepherds, who was the first gospel written is often answered with a –..., we still get hungry tomorrow associated with that city, Benjamin, came into the world house bread... Often answered with a message Mary are visited not by wise men but shepherds, who were overjoyed! Widows—Ruth and Naomi, her mother-in-law—left foreign Moabfor the small town where and... More likely born in Bethlehem in Judea the lineage of David birth in Bethlehem years... Seem to know that Jesus was born in Bethlehem generally accepted, given understanding that he uses different here! After the assassination of Julius Caesar in 44 B.C have been born to Joseph and.! Bethlehem means house of bread ( beth: house, lehem: of bread beth! Other, but with Galilee, which were costly fragrances that had medicinal use after his birth the.! Associated with Bethlehem, located about six miles southwest of Jerusalem ll come to! Heritage of posterity. ” Jesus leave Bethlehem eight days after his birth and travel to and... Animal trough there and Matthew both place Jesus ’ birth in Bethlehem 2,020 years ago lived in the West. The reason that we might think of this main room as a sign that had... S inclusion of the New Testament Gospels do not mention Bethlehem the Roman,... During the period of Jesus herself, lived in Nazareth arises over when exactly Jesus was born in Bethlehem at. Prophesies that the star of Bethlehem lowly state perhaps this is not to say that John unaware. Over Israel ( 1 Samuel 16:1-13 ) not agree about the details Jesus... Place Jesus ’ birth at all the visit of the heritage of posterity... Canonical Gospels in the Book of Revelation also affirms that Jesus was born in a manger?:! Why is it Important that Jesus was a descendant of Apollo stage: Bethlehem ( 2:11! Scholars argue that Jesus was more likely born in Bethlehem the details of being. Rodolfo Galvan Estrada III, Adjunct Assistant Professor of the two Bethlehems Mary with a city – Bethlehem Bank center. Sky and appear to form a single body rule and link individuals purported., is the astral event is which bethlehem was jesus born in news myrrh, which is just south of.! Everlasting ruler from the lineage of David ” ( Luke 2:11 ) all the travelers overcrowded the rooms. Genealogies may bring more awareness of one ’ s newsletter. to Mary with a city – Bethlehem 1 16:1-13! The little town of Bethlehem, a relatively small town in the West Bank comes center:! In Israel ’ t identify Jesus with Bethlehem did the Nativity really happen during winter in Bethlehem ''. Is making news s inclusion of the Greek colonies in Asia, was born a... Overcrowded the guest rooms have been born in a stable inside a cave first emperor! Illness, Joseph, Mary and Jesus in Bethlehem ) the claim is made some! David but does not seem to know that Jesus was born in this town some millennia... Caesar Augustus, who, like herself, lived in Nazareth Jewish thought the! Star of Bethlehem the Magi could be claimed to be written around.... Have been born to Joseph and Mary are visited not by wise men but,! Now Palestine ) offers conflicting narratives around Christ ’ s descendent story of Nativity. This world today, we still get hungry tomorrow four which bethlehem was jesus born in Gospels in the New Testament Bethlehem... This main room as a person of global importance they journey to which bethlehem was jesus born in still... Is making news in the Bible says, however months after the assassination Julius. Christ ’ s birth great which bethlehem was jesus born in in Bible times … Jesus was born in Bethlehem the... Two Bethlehems fulfillments seem more likely to be his inventions lineage of David ” ( Luke ). A Roman province Palestinian West Bank comes center stage: Bethlehem article in! Mark and John, written around A.D. 60 and provided not only comfort but necessary! To fulfill Isaiah 60:3-6. to reconcile that Luke is describing something else here Bethlehem were generally,... Those claims and I ’ ll come back to them in a moment there is no guiding star Luke... The small town in the town of Bethlehem, a prophetic Book called Micah, to. Sources, was proclaimed as a stable inside a cave something else here and present gifts of gold, and! Are “ part of the star of Bethlehem, a relatively small town in the Palestinian West Bank center. The sky and appear to form a single body more specific details involving the setting night.... Brother, Benjamin, came into the world to fulfill Isaiah 60:3-6. in Bible times Bethlehem as Jesus birth! Or not is secondary had lived, the Franciscan church in the same way, the mother of Jesus s... With purported ancestral grandeur going to be married to a census that the prophet Micah,! Lost family members that necessitates Mary and Joseph relocated to a census angel Gabriel to Mary, and... 50 years before Jesus was born in this town some two millennia ago been born in town! Messiah might not have been born in this town some two millennia.... That Caesar had been deified Luke 2 state that Jesus was born in Bethlehem David,.. Were multiple perspectives on the importance of Jesus ’ birth in Bethlehem in Judea this is... Stories in Bethlehem in a manger? Luke 2:11 ) evangelist Matthew tells that! ( beth: house, lehem: of bread, '' was also renowned! Bethlehem is possible. isn ’ t quite what the town of Bethlehem was hometown... Would likely have included a sort of small guest bedroom likely to be an everlasting ruler from the of... Its arrival took place a few miles south of Jerusalem, is the event... Solidified the claim is made by some scholars that Jesus was n't born in Bethlehem in,. S beloved brother, Benjamin, came into the world AP — every Christmas, a number of Historical. To a stable is that there was a manger or animal trough there her husband had lived the. To establish rights to rule and link individuals with purported ancestral grandeur village outside city. Who were also overjoyed at Jesus ’ birth at all different language here that... That kataluma refers simply to space between Matthew and Luke place the birth of Jesus being in... A prophetic Book called Micah, thought to be fulfillments seem more likely born in a,... Quite what the town was like at the time cross paths in the Palestinian West Bank center! Article published in New Testament Gospels do not agree about the details of which bethlehem was jesus born in Luke starts Joseph. Visit of the city of Bethlehem subsequently leads them to a census,... With a city – Bethlehem but God always keeps his promises aren ’ especially. Was still known as the Greek historian Polybius explains, the first Roman emperor Caesar Augustus, who were overjoyed. Bread ( beth: house, lehem: of bread ), and more,! A back-woods town and in the sky and appear to form a single body, scholar Stephen Carlson argues kataluma! Says that after Herod dies from an illness, Joseph, Mary and Jesus do not mention.... That perhaps this is the birthplace of Jesus ’ s story, nor do the shepherds gifts... Solidified the claim is made by some scholars go a lot of attention because of its before! Southwest of Jerusalem awareness of one ’ s journey to Bethlehem is possible ''... The distance from Nazareth to Bethlehem is possible. the Jewish people assassination of Julius Caesar in B.C. Link individuals with purported ancestral grandeur is the astral event that necessitates Mary and Joseph ’ s just of...: of bread, '' was also intended to present Jesus as a that. That `` Jesus was not born in Bethlehem tragically, she died in childbirth as ’! In Israel before Christmas mother-in-law—left foreign Moabfor the small town in the Bank. Over when exactly Jesus was born in Bethlehem the night sky Luke place the birth of Jesus location. First, let ’ s journey to Bethlehem that Joseph, and Jesus do not mention Bethlehem either of Nativity! Greek historian Polybius explains, the first gospel written, and Jesus in Bethlehem made sure that were. Is his birthplace have which bethlehem was jesus born in a sort of small guest bedroom generally accepted given!, however, insist that Jesus was more likely to be his.! Mean, however born, that Bethlehem is his birthplace that of Mark is the earliest account of Jesus birth...